Latest Posts

Form 9423 Is the Fast IRS Appeal (And the One No Court Reviews)

Form 9423 Is the Fast IRS Appeal (And the One No Court Reviews)

Form 9423 is the request for a Collection Appeals Program review. It lets you take a levy, a seizure, a federal tax lien, or a rejected, modified or terminated installment agreement to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals, usually faster than a Collection Due Process hearing. The trade is finality, because no court reviews Appeals’ CAP decision.

Speed matters because the deadlines here are counted in business days, not weeks. If a revenue officer has told you a levy is coming, or a letter has just rejected your payment plan, call us before the manager conference. We handle these appeals for clients from our Washington, DC office, and the first conversation is where most of the record gets made.

What Is Form 9423 For?

Form 9423 asks the IRS Independent Office of Appeals to review a collection action under the Collection Appeals Program. The form’s instructions list levies and seizures, a Notice of Federal Tax Lien, denied lien certificates such as a withdrawal or discharge, rejected, modified or terminated installment agreements, and denied requests to return levied property.

What CAP can’t do is argue the tax. Publication 1660 says you may not challenge the existence or amount of the liability in CAP, so if the balance itself is wrong, you need a different route. Third parties can use it too, for instance when the IRS files a lien against property it says a taxpayer holds through a nominee or alter ego, and those parties have no CDP rights at all.

CAP Against a CDP Hearing

The choice comes down to speed and reach against court review. Publication 1660 says CAP generally produces a quicker Appeals decision and covers a broader range of collection actions, but you can’t go to court if you disagree with the result. A CDP hearing is only available after specific notices and inside a 30-day window, and it keeps the Tax Court in play.

So if you’ve received a final notice of intent to levy or a lien filing notice and you’re still inside those 30 days, we usually look at CDP first, and our guide to requesting a CDP hearing on Form 12153 covers that filing. CAP fits what CDP doesn’t reach. That includes a seizure, a terminated or modified payment plan, a levy where the CDP window has closed, or a week where days matter more than appeal rights. For the hearing itself, see how a collection due process hearing works.

The Conference With the Collection Manager Comes First

For a lien, levy or seizure, CAP starts with a conversation rather than the form. If your only contact so far has been a notice or a phone call, you call the number on the notice, explain which action you disagree with and why, and offer a solution. If you can’t agree with the employee, you ask for their manager. Publication 1660 says the manager will either speak with you then or return your call within 24 hours, and if you still disagree, the case goes to Appeals without a written request.

A revenue officer’s case runs on a tighter track. You request a conference with the Collection manager first. If that doesn’t resolve it, you tell the revenue officer or manager within two business days of the conference that you’re appealing, and your Form 9423 has to be postmarked within three business days of the conference, or collection can resume. If no manager contacts you within two business days of your request, you can send the form anyway, and it should be received or postmarked within four business days of that request.

A seizure has its own clock. You have to appeal to the Collection manager within ten business days after the Notice of Seizure is given to you or left at your home or business.

Card naming the three separate CAP appeal deadlines

Three different actions, three different clocks, and none of them is generous.

How to Fill Out Form 9423

The form is a single page, and most of it is identification. Blocks 1 through 13 take your name, your representative, taxpayer identification number, contact details, the type of tax, the periods you’re appealing and the amount due. A representative attaches Form 2848. Block 14 is where you tick the actions you’re appealing, from the lien and levy boxes to the three installment agreement boxes.

Card showing the three parts of a completed Form 9423

Most of the page is identification. Block 15 is the only part that argues.

The explanation that decides it

Block 15 is the appeal. The form asks you to explain why you disagree with each checked action and how you would resolve the tax problem, and Publication 1660 makes the second half a requirement, not a courtesy. A proposal Appeals can test carries far more weight than an objection. If you’re proposing a payment arrangement, build it from your actual finances, and our note on what the IRS accepts on a payment plan shows how those figures get set.

What to attach

Attach copies of any documents that support your position, and keep them tied to the argument in block 15. The instructions say Appeals will generally ask Collection to review and comment on new information, and you’ll get a chance to respond to those comments. You sign under penalties of perjury, and Publication 1660 warns that false information, leaving out pertinent information, or fraud will void Appeals’ decision.

How to Send Form 9423 to the IRS, and the Deadlines That Apply

For a lien, levy or seizure, the form goes to the Collection office involved in the action, not to Appeals. For an installment agreement, it goes to the office or revenue officer who took the action, and the instructions are blunt that you should never forward it directly to Appeals.

The installment agreement deadlines are counted in calendar days. A rejection has to be appealed on or before the 30th day after the date of the rejection letter, and a mailed request has to be postmarked by then. For a proposed termination you have 30 days from the notice of intent to terminate, and the right to appeal continues for another 30 days after a termination takes effect. Publication 1660 adds that the IRS can’t levy until 30 days after a rejection or termination, and an appeal filed inside that period bars a levy until the appeal is complete unless the IRS believes collection is in jeopardy.

Because so much turns on the postmark, send the form by a method that proves the mailing date, and keep a copy of everything. Once an appeal is in, the IRS normally stops the collection action you’re disputing until the appeal is settled, unless it believes collection is at risk. If a wage levy is already running, our note on relief once a wage levy has started covers the options alongside an appeal.

What We Look At Before Recommending CAP

We start with the calendar. If a CDP window is still open, giving up Tax Court review for speed needs a reason. Next we ask whether the dispute is really about the collection action or about the tax, because CAP won’t hear the second. Then we check whether we can put a credible alternative in block 15, backed by the client’s financial facts. For a business, we also check whether the levy is a disqualified employment tax levy, which Publication 1660 treats as an exception to the usual pause.

James A. Kraehenbuehl began his career at Boies Schiller and Flexner, representing clients before regulatory agencies and in state and federal courts, and he’s an attorney and CPA licensed in the District. That background shapes how we treat CAP. When Appeals’ decision binds both sides and no court follows, the written record has to be complete the first time.

If you’re holding a levy notice, a lien notice, or a rejection of your payment plan, talk to us about appealing an IRS collection action. Every case starts with a free consultation, and on a CAP timeline it’s worth having that call today.

FAQ

What is form 9423 for?

It’s the Collection Appeal Request. You use it to ask the IRS Independent Office of Appeals to review a lien, a levy, a seizure, or a rejected, modified or terminated installment agreement under the Collection Appeals Program.

How to fill out form 9423?

Complete the identification blocks, tick the collection actions you’re appealing in block 14, and use block 15 to explain why you disagree and how you’d resolve the balance. Attach supporting documents, add Form 2848 if a representative signs, and sign under penalties of perjury.

How to send form 9423 to IRS?

Send it to the Collection office involved in the lien, levy or seizure, or to the office or revenue officer who acted on your installment agreement, never directly to Appeals. Use a mailing method that proves the postmark date, because the deadlines are counted from it.

Share Post:

Recent Post

New Jersey’s Pension Exclusion Has an Income Cliff Worth Planning Around

New Jersey’s pension exclusion lets a resident who, at year-end, is 62 or older or...

How Long the IRS Has to Assess a Trust Fund Recovery Penalty

Three years, in most cases. The IRS generally has to assess a trust fund recovery...

Does Maryland Tax Capital Gains Differently From Your Paycheck?

Not at a lower rate. Maryland taxes a capital gain as ordinary income, at the...

subscribe to our newsletter

Get notified when we publish new blog posts.